Skincare Myth: “If It Tingles, It’s Working”

We’ve all had that moment: you apply a product, feel the tingling start, and think "This must be doing something."

But here’s the truth: tingling isn’t a sign of effectiveness- it’s often a sign of irritation.

This persistent myth has led many people to associate discomfort with results. In reality, great skincare shouldn’t sting, burn, or cause redness- especially if you have sensitive or reactive skin. Let’s unpack what that tingling actually means, and how to know when it’s not okay.

Why Tingling Happens in Skincare

Tingling or stinging sensations typically happen when:

• A product contains harsh exfoliants (like strong acids or scrubs)

• Your skin barrier is compromised, leaving nerves more exposed

• The formula includes irritating ingredients like alcohols, fragrance, or menthol

• You’re layering too many actives at once (like retinol + vitamin C + acids)

Sometimes a mild tingle is expected- like with certain exfoliating masks or chemical peels. But regular stinging from daily-use products? That’s a red flag.

Tingling Isn’t Proof of Efficacy

Many harsh ingredients may “feel” like they’re working because they create an immediate sensation or redness- but that doesn't mean they’re effective long-term.

In fact, repeated irritation weakens your skin barrier, increasing sensitivity, breakouts, dryness, and inflammation. Over time, your skin can become more reactive and less able to tolerate even gentle ingredients.

What to Look for Instead of Sensation

You don’t need a reaction to get results. The most effective skincare ingredients are the ones that:

• Work below the surface to calm, balance, or support healthy function

• Improve tone and texture gradually, without causing visible irritation

• Are backed by science, not just marketing claims

What We Recommend Instead

At Alder New York, we believe skincare should feel good and actually be good for your skin. That’s why our formulas are:

• Free from synthetic fragrance and dyes

• Third-party tested and verified by the EWG

• Powered by proven, plant-based ingredients that support and not stress out your skin

Our favorites for calm, results-driven care:

• Balancing Serum
  5% niacinamide + willow bark for clearer, smoother skin- without sting.

• Nourishing Cream
  Jojoba oil and bakuchiol hydrate and help reduce fine lines without irritation.

• Clarifying Face Mask
  Gentle yet effective, with zinc oxide, and willow bark to calm and reset skin.

Bottom Line: Results Shouldn’t Burn

Tingling might feel satisfying in the moment, but it’s not a requirement for great skincare. In fact, it may be a sign your skin needs a gentler, more supportive approach.

So the next time your skin doesn’t react? That’s a win. It means your barrier is intact, your routine is working, and your skin can focus on being its best self.